Costco Pizza - Tastes Like A Tuesday

3.5 stars Review Philosophy

Costco Pizza Takeaway. Tastes like a Tuesday. The "everyman pizza". 5/10 pizza. A baseline pizza we can all compare against. Insane value at $10/pizza. Limited options with only cheese and pepperoni. Need to be a member. Parking is easy and convenient with the new UCity location off of I-170. Tip: Call ahead and order via the food court saves waiting there for 20+ minutes.

Table Of Contents: Experience | Food | Atmosphere | Receipt

Costco Pizza measurement


  • 8685 Olive Blvd, St. Louis, MO 63132
  • (314) 219-5154
  • Website
  • Google Maps - 4.5 stars - 940 ratings


Monday10 AM–8:30 PM
Tuesday10 AM–8:30 PM
Wednesday10 AM–8:30 PM
Thursday10 AM–8:30 PM
Friday10 AM–8:30 PM
Saturday9:30 AM–6 PM
Sunday10 AM–6 PM


Costco Pizza Experience Summary

If you're wondering why the heck I'm reviewing Costco pizza in St. Louis, it's because I need a baseline.

To do any future pizza reviews, we all need to agree on what an average pizza experience will be, and Costco Pizza meets that criteria for me. It's a solid 5/10.

Costco Pizza box

It's better tasting and value than Dominos, to me, and worthy of the average rating. If you want to compare Costco to Dominos, Dominos is a 4/10 to me.

Not enough people have had Sam's Club, and I haven't had Papa John's or Pizza Hut in years, so I couldn't use those as a baseline.

Costco is also an insane value at $10 for an 18" cheese pizza.

Costco Pizza measurement

Therefore, it's my staple Tuesday night pizza on the way home from daycare and my choice for the "everyman" comparison.

When you start a St. Louis food blog, you can pick your baseline. :)

The Food At Costco Pizza

An 18-inch Costco plain pizza costs 40 cents less than a Domino's 14-inch hand-tossed pizza.

I'll let that sink in for a minute…


That's 65% more pizza for $.40 less because of math. The area of a circle is the radius squared, which means those 4 inches in diameter account for 32 square inches in area.

Costco Pizza vs dominos price for comparison

Now that we have the math out of the way, we can get on to taste.

Costco Pizza tastes like a Tuesday.

You're excited because you're eating pizza, but realize it's not the weekend. Solid 5 / 10 makes it the "Everyman's Pizza".

The pizza is doughier than a typical New York-style pizza but has the proper ratio of sauce and cheese to bread. The cheese tastes like mozzarella, and the sauce has tomatoes in it.

You're not gonna bring your parents here for dinner, but you'll enjoy it enough, considering the calories you're consuming.

The most important tip: Call ahead and order your pizza(s) for pickup. This saves you the 20 to 30 minutes you'd be stuck waiting there if you just go and order it. Additionally, you pay via the kiosk, select "Called in Pizza", and then show them the receipt to get it.

Costco Pizza food court

To round out a meal, you can pick up a chicken Caesar salad and a frozen yogurt for an extra $10.

Costco Pizza Atmosphere And Miscellaneous

It's in Costco, so you'll need a membership.

The UCity Costco is new, clean, and friendly. Just walk in past the membership desk to the food court.

Order from the kiosk, talk to the nice people behind the counter and get home in time before it gets cold.

Parking At Costco Pizza

Parking at Costco is straightforward. There's a giant parking lot, and they just added it off of I-170, so you don't have to drive too far away. It's on my way home from daycare, so it's smooth sailing.

Costco Pizza Receipt

Costco Pizza receipt

Related Saint Louis Restaurant Reviews

Join The Newsletter

Weekly reviews of restaurant, parks, and things to do All Around Saint Louis.