Google thinks almost every restaurant in St. Louis is great. Across the 153 restaurants I've reviewed, 85% of them sit between 4.3 and 4.8 stars on Google. That's a 0.5-star window to sort out the best meal in town from the one that ruined my Tuesday.
So I lined up every restaurant, park and attraction I've scored against its Google and Yelp ratings to see if the stars tell you anything.
Everything is a 4.6

The median Google rating for the restaurants I've reviewed is 4.6. Three out of four are 4.5 or higher.
Yelp spreads things out more, from a 1.9 up to a 5.0. My scores spread out the most, from a 3.6 to a 10.
To compare them, I doubled Google and Yelp so everything sits on a 10-point scale. A 4.6 on Google is a 9.2.
Same Google rating, wildly different meals

This is the chart that made me want to write this. Google gives 34 of the restaurants I've reviewed a 4.7.
That list includes Union Loafers, my favorite restaurant in St. Louis and a 10.0. It also includes AKAR, which I scored a 6.0. The drunken noodles were great, but at $39 they're almost three Cate Zones.
Google can't tell those two apart.
The stars don't follow the food

If Google's stars told you how good a meal would be, the dots would climb from bottom left to top right. They don't. They pile up in a column between 4.3 and 4.8, and inside that column my scores run from 3.6 to 10.
For the stats people: the correlation between Google's star rating and my score is 0.26. Yelp is 0.28. Both are weak.
What my numbers mean

A star rating is only useful if you know what it means. Here's what mine mean:
- 7.0 is restaurant quality. I call it the Flood Line. It's the best you could do at home with good ingredients and some practice. Crossing it means the place is making something you can't easily make yourself.
- 8.0 is worth a 10-minute drive. I'd go a little out of my way for it.
- 9.0 is worth driving 25 minutes or more. It's where I take out-of-town guests.
Food is 60% of my score and price is 30% (full breakdown here). Service and atmosphere split the last 10%.
Out of 153 restaurants, 30 are 9 or higher, 76 are in the 8s and 35 are in the 7s. Twelve fell below the Flood Line.
Review count helps a little
The star rating doesn't tell you much. The number of reviews tells you a bit more.

Of the restaurants with 1,000+ Google reviews, 23% scored a 9 or higher with me. For places under 200 reviews, it was 11%. The flops go the other way, 7% under 7 for the busy places vs. 11% for the small ones.
So if you're stuck using Google, look at the count before the stars. A 4.7 with 1,500 reviews is a safer bet than a 4.7 with 80. It's still only a slightly safer bet.
And Yelp?
Yelp is gnarlier. It uses more of the scale than Google, but the spread doesn't line up with mine any better (0.28 vs Google's 0.26).
Yelp is also how I ended up at Gelato Di Riso. It was the highest-rated dessert place open at 9 p.m. on a Saturday. I gave it a 4.0 and would rather have had a pint of Ben & Jerry's.
Where Google and I disagree the most

The biggest gaps are almost all one direction. Google likes a place and I don't.
Most of them are sandwiches, because I weigh every sandwich and score it on meat per dollar. Protzel's is a 4.6 on Google and a 3.6 from me. The pastrami was stringy, the bread was stale and the "8 oz" of meat weighed 6.8.
Going the other way is harder, because Google rarely drops below 4.3. El Guanaco is the biggest one. It's a 4.3 on Google and a 9.6 from me, thanks to a $7.99 baleada especial with chorizo, steak, chicken, queso, eggs, avocado and cream.
Parks are even flatter
Google's park ratings are even more squeezed together than its restaurant ratings. All 24 parks I've reviewed sit between 4.2 and 4.9 on Google, while my scores run from 4.2 to 10.
Review count mattered more for parks. The five parks with 1,000+ Google reviews averaged a 9.1 from me, and the nine under 200 averaged a 7.4. That's a small sample, so take it loosely.
The catch
My scores skew high, and that's on purpose. I don't pick restaurants at random. I go where I think the food will be good, so most of my reviews land in the 8s.
Google and Yelp ratings are also from September 2026, and they move. A few of these places will have shifted by the time you read this.
Bottom line
A Google count tells you a place is popular. It won't tell you if it's worth a 25-minute drive.
If you want the 9s, here's every review.